Note: This article was originally posted on 8/23/2013. For more on this historic Idaho hero, see my “Hill Beachey Project” pages.
The one hundred fiftieth anniversary of October 24, 1863 falls on October 24, 2013. I suggest we celebrate it, make it a public holiday in Idaho. I propose it be named “Hill Beachey Day.” Idaho’s legislature could declare it an official state holiday, to be celebrated annually, in next year’s legislative session.
This was the day, in 1863, when Hill Beachey set out from Lewiston to track down and return to justice three men named James Romaine, David Renton, and George Christopher Lower. They, he strongly suspected, had murdered Lloyd Magruder, Charles Allen, William Phillips, and the brothers Horace and Robert Chalmers, which crime has become collectively known as the “Magruder murders.” Not much about murders isn’t disputed or rendered differently by different historians and writers. Yet, the story’s main elements are clear enough. It was one of the most ghastly and notorious crimes in the history of the American West. It also tested for the first time the new justice system of the new Idaho Territory.
Lloyd Magruder took a pack train of mules loaded with mining supplies and other goods from Lewiston to the Alder Gulch mining camps in the summer of 1863. He set up shop in Virginia City, where he soon sold out his wares. In early October, he started back toward Lewiston, now with unloaded mules but carrying considerable gold dust from his successful trading venture. En route, Magruder and his crew were brutally and cold-bloodedly killed by the three men (and perhaps a fourth), who were ostensibly traveling with the company as helpers.
The killers then made their way to Lewiston and booked passage on the stagecoach to Walla Walla, going from there to San Francisco. How, exactly, they aroused suspicions as they passed through Lewiston is a matter of considerable debate. Some accounts, going back to Nathaniel Langford’s semi-fictionalized account in his Vigilante Days and Ways (1890), emphasized the importance of a prophetic dream Hill Beachey, Magruder’s friend and owner-manager of the Luna House hotel in Lewiston, is supposed to have had, in which Beachey foresaw Magruder’s murder by an axe-wielding Chris Lower. But Julia Conway Welch, whose book, The Magruder Murders: Coping with Violence on the Idaho Frontier (1991), offers arguably the most scholarly and sober rendering of this history, makes a strong case against the dream and its role, suggesting Langford introduced it merely for dramatic effect. One nearly contemporary newspaper account reported that suspicions gathered around the fact that the suspects abandoned fine horses and expensive gear in Lewiston without making any provision for their sale. Perhaps there is even something to historian Hubert Howe Bancroft’s suggestion that Beachey saw “the mark of Cain, which seldom fails to be visible” in the suspects. Whatever the full array of suspicion-exciting clues may have been, on October 24th Hill Beachey, accompanied and assisted by Thomas Farrell, headed out of Lewiston to track down and bring to justice the suspects.
It’s well to pause, here, and consider some of the remarkable features of Beachey’s fateful decision. He was not a trained lawman or tracker. His absence would be costly. He had at least two businesses to run in Lewiston – a stagecoach line as well as the hotel – and he had other new projects in progress in town as well. He did not know the four suspects names or much about them. He did not know where they were headed or whether they would all travel together or soon split up and go in different directions. His decision obliged him to leave the comforts of home and the warm bed he shared with his wife. He’d be gone for an unknown length of time and at his own expense. Moreover, he could not be one hundred percent certain that his friend Magruder had actually met with foul play. Finally, believing that the men he pursued were coldblooded killers, giving chase would obviously expose him to no little danger and peril. Yet Beachey, despite all of the above, decided to embark all the same.
The suspects had a several-days head start on him. The trail Beachey and Farrell picked up indicated they’d boarded a steamer for San Francisco at Portland. Rather than wait for another steamer’s departure, Beachy headed overland, by stage, to Yreka, California, the first place with telegraph service to San Francisco. There, he wired police chief Martin Burke requesting that the men be detained. Burke, in turn, assigned the case to Isaiah Lees, his department’s crack detective. Lees soon found and arrested the suspects. The suspects made a substantial deposit of gold dust at the San Francisco Mint for conversion to coin. The police’s unearthing of this clue speeded their capture.
But the apprehended suspects were not without resources and soon hired a lawyer to fight their extradition to Idaho Territory. The question of whether the police department should surrender the prisoners to Beachey was kicked up to the governor’s office in Sacramento. California’s Governor Leland Stanford apparently met with Beachey and issued an order for the prisoners’ transfer to him on November 2nd, 1863. Meantime, a habeas corpus suit filed on the prisoners’ behalf was making its way through California’s judicial system. Among other points, the suspects’ lawyer argued that the U.S. Constitution made no specific provision for extradition from a U.S. state to a U.S. territory. On November 11th, after a second day of hearing the case, Justice Edwin B. Crocker announced from the bench that the defendants’ writ was denied and a written opinion would follow “as soon as practicable.” Beachey now took custody of the prisoners and, from San Francisco, soon boarded the steamer Pacific for Portland. Below the mouth of the Williamette River his party transferred to the steamer Julia. They were henceforth accompanied by a military guard provided by General Alvord at Vancouver. “Steam had been kept on the Julia for more than thirty hours, awaiting their arrival,” reported the Portland Oregonian. At Walla Walla, Beachey’s party once again transferred, this time to a stagecoach for the final leg to Lewiston.
The three alleged killers were tried in Lewiston in January, 1864. A fourth man, Billy Page, pleaded that he took no part in the killings and testified against the other three. Page was spared. Considerable care was taken that the defendants received a fair trial. A contemporary newspaper account noted:
It might not be inappropriate to say that this trial, conducted so formally and orderly, will be productive of much good in this country. It is the first session of the District Court ever held in the Territory, and the first cause tried, and one unparalleled in brutality of design and accomplishment ever placed in the records of crime.
The trial’s outcome would also become the first legally sanctioned execution in Idaho Territory, held on March 4th, 1864, the first anniversary of the territory’s creation.
What can mere words add about Beachey’s brave and loyal service to his friend, Lloyd Magruder? Giving chase, as he did — with so little evidence to go on, so much risk to face, and what must have seemed no great prospect of success – was an action that would become stamped indelibly Idaho Territory’s early history. His ultimate success also marked him as a man who could effectively surmount challenges and bring even the most difficult and trying task to completion. Idaho’s territorial legislature granted Beachey $6,244 “for money expended, and time employed” in the capture and return of the three murderers. This was a tidy sum in 1864, to be sure. Yet, it doesn’t seem quite sufficient somehow. Without his courageous decision, the Magruder murders would have become lodged in Idaho’s history without the closure wrought by justice well served. It elevates Idaho’s historical story to know that the first year of the Territory’s existence witnessed Hill Beachey’s towering act of friendship, loyalty, courage, and commitment to justice.
So, yeah, I say let’s create an Hill Beachey Day on Idaho’s calendar, starting October 24, 2013! Keeping his memory alive seems entirely fitting.